For Comparison’s Sake: Boat Shoes

Want to know the favorite boat shoes of Boating’s editors? Take a look at what we wore during our fall boat tests.

You could call this the ultimate smell test. Want to know the favorite boat shoes of Boating’s editors? Take a whiff, or at least a look, at what we wore during our fall boat tests.

Reef Leather Fannings ($51,
Worn them since: Summer 2006

Why they’re my faves: They hold my foot snugly and fit the length perfectly. Support at the arch and around the heel makes them comfortable. In spite of a few hundred dunkings at the launch ramp, they still hold together.


Way better than: Closed shoes are too hot in the South. Half the time I flip my flops in a compartment and go barefoot until my feet get tired of the hard deck.

Moment of truth: When I dig through my closet, pulling out all manner of boat shoes, to grab the Reefs for a boating weekend.

On the other…hand: There’s a bottle cap puller in the sole. (I use it sparingly since our dogs roam the yard.) Though it hasn’t damaged my boat’s deck, I wish they’d make these sandals without it. — Randy Vance


Merrell Running Shoes ($105,
Worn them since: August 2007

Why they’re my faves: Super light, these shoes offer tremendous cushion and support while I’m on my feet running a boat all day. The soles really grip wet decks.

Way better than: Boat shoes, tennis shoes or basketball shoes. Mostly mesh, they drain right out when spray, the hose or a blocked scupper cause my feet to get wet. Designed for all-weather running, they dry quickly and are odor free (at least in salt water).


Moment of truth: Playing monkey bars on the tower of a sportfish some 80 miles offshore while trying to fix a busted outrigger fitting: My hands were busy so sure footing was all I had.

On the other…hand: I had to change out the silly round laces that came with them because they wouldn’t stay tied. They now sport old-school flat laces. — Kevin Falvey

Maui Surf Aloha ($62,
Worn them since: March 2008


Why they’re my faves: They’re the lightest shoes I’ve ever worn, about 10 ounces apiece, which is like slippers. When I first put them on, I thought they’d get wet and tear as easily as tissue paper. They did (get wet) and didn’t (fall apart).

Way better than: Flip-flops or sandals. My feet get sunburned in sandals, and I’m a firm believer that unless a guy is barefoot he has no reason to show his hairy toes.

Moment of truth: The first time I wore them on a rough boat ramp, they got soaked. But they drained quickly, and water didn’t squish out for the next three days.

On the other…hand: They’ve stretched quite a bit and they look dorky with socks (or maybe it’s just me). — Robert Stephens

OTB Harbor ($99,
Worn them since: June 2007

Why they’re my faves: They have a look and feel similar to traditional leather boat shoes, but they stay way cooler in summer and have a removable insole that provides good arch support when I’m standing a long deck watch.

Way better than: Those leather boat shoes. They don’t stink when they get wet, they dry quickly, and they’re easier to clean (not that I’ve ever done so).

Moment of truth: Bought at the same time as a pair of OTB Leader slip-ons, but didn’t actually wear them until the other pair went missing. Since then, they’re the perennial first choice.

On the other…hand: You still have to tie your shoes instead of stepping in and out like you can with moccasins and some old-school lace-ups. — Pierce Hoover


Email Newsletters and Special Offers

Sign up for Boating emails to receive features on travel destinations, event listings and product reviews as well as special offers on behalf of Boating’s partners.

By signing up you agree to receive communications from Boating and select partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy. You may opt out of email messages/withdraw consent at any time.