Hot Rod Challenge

We test three of the hottest fishing rods available.

I was at Bass Pro Shops recently, staring down a techno-forest of graphite, fiberglass, cork and ceramic rods. Then I did the test shake, waving the rods in swift arcs to try to imagine the castability of each. Then it struck me — in our offices we have a dozen top angling editors, and I could pit them against each other to test-cast my three finalists. The competition was heated — so heated we decided to leave the editors, well, anonymous. How did the rods cast?

We set up each rod with a Quantum Energy ei30PTsB reel and spooled first with 12-pound monofilament Sufix line, and then with 20-pound Berkley Spiderwire. Our casting plug was a five-inch soft plastic jerk bait. Here’s how they stacked up.

Quantum Specks and Reds
Think PGA golf. With the burnt orange finish, you’d think you were using a Phil Mickelson driver — and indeed, this limber rod drives feathery to chunky lures deep into the wind. Action is ideal for flicking out live bait or scented plastics — and imparting the perfect action. High end, sporty power.


Action: Light/Fast
Length: 7’0″ one-piece
Guides: American Tackle Titan with titanium for max corrosion resistance
Handle Material: Cork with Fuji DPS seat
Line Weight Rating: 8 to 17
Lure Weight Rating:
1/16 to 5/8
Average Casting Distance w/Mono: 93’4″ w/Braid: 101’8″
Bottom Line: $219.95;

Shimano Teramar Southeast Inshore Series
Darn near custom look and feel with graphite construction so deep, lustrous and shiny — think of the eyes of your first high school date. The rod balanced perfectly in our hands, and its fast tip spoke to accuracy, but it fell just a tad short of hitting the top distance — probably due to its stiffer midsection.

Action: Medium/Fast
Length: 7’0″ one-piece**
Guides:** New Concept Fuji Hardloy for smooth casts and abrasion resistance
Handle Material: Cork with Fuji reel seat
Line Weight Rating: 8 to 17
Lure Weight Rating: 3/8 to 1
Average Casting Distance w/Mono: 92’6″ w/Braid: 101’1″
Bottom Line:


Berkley Cobalt Fire
Stiffer from butt to tip, the medium-action rod was, on paper, the bluntest tool in the shed. But not in the hands of three casters who easily whipped out nearly 100-foot casts. The look is polished, well-built and competent. Think Chevy Tahoe, loaded, but not a Porsche Cayenne.

Action: Medium
Length: 7’0″ one-piece
Guides: Pacific Bay Tiblue; corrosion resistant, ideal for abrasive braids
Handle Material: Cork with proprietary Berkley reel seats
Line Weight Rating: 8 to 20
Lure Weight Rating: 1/4 to 5/8
Average Casting Distance w/Mono: 92’2″ w/Braid: 100’8″
Bottom Line: $79.99;

Braid vs Mono
They are like different guns in the locker — each with unique strengths and weaknesses. Mono is easier to knot and handle; braid gets hopelessly tangled more easily but makes up for it in more strength for less diameter and no-stretch limpness that feeds easily through the guides. In our test, casting distance was an obvious benefit. When averaging three casts by three expert casters, Berkley Spiderwire 20-pound braid outcast 12-pound Sufix mono by almost nine feet. That’s why it costs the big bucks.


Email Newsletters and Special Offers

Sign up for Boating emails to receive features on travel destinations, event listings and product reviews as well as special offers on behalf of Boating’s partners.

By signing up you agree to receive communications from Boating and select partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy. You may opt out of email messages/withdraw consent at any time.